We were recently working with the executive committee of a global retailer. Midway through their digital transformation, two regional directors disagreed sharply on whether to double down on mobile commerce or invest in physical experience centres. Rather than rushing to a vote, we asked each to record their key premises, expected outcomes and worst-case scenarios in a decision journal. Two weeks later, the team reconvened. Reviewing those entries revealed a shared over-reliance on last year’s holiday sales data and an overlooked assumption about store footfall trends. With clarity on their blind spots, they realigned swiftly - and avoided a multimillion-pound misstep.

Strategic significance

Decision-making isn’t just a process - it’s a muscle that atrophies without exercise. According to McKinsey, executives who systematically review their decisions improve success rates by 25 per cent. This matters because in volatile markets, speed alone isn’t enough. Leaders need to learn fast, adjust course and institutionalise insights. A decision journal acts as both mirror and compass - helping teams spot cognitive biases, refine mental models and embed continuous improvement.

‍

The Framework: The 4-Part Decision Journal Loop

Part 1 – Capture Context

We encourage leaders to start by noting the trigger, stakes and time horizon. Frame the question clearly: What choice am I facing and why does it matter now? Example: “Should we reallocate 20 per cent of our R&D budget to AI pilots given emerging competition?”

Reflection prompt: What isn’t captured in my usual briefing pack?
Micro-action: Draft the decision question and one sentence on urgency.

Part 2 – Articulate Assumptions

List the three to five key beliefs underpinning your choice. Be explicit: sales forecasts, customer behaviour, competitive moves. In one software firm, failing to call out an assumption about 90 per cent mobile adoption led to misaligned product design.

Reflection prompt: Which of these assumptions would shift if proven false?
Micro-action: Write each assumption as “I believe X because…”.

Part 3 – Forecast Outcomes

Estimate best, likely and worst-case scenarios with brief rationale. We’ve seen boards skip this and then wonder why plans unravel when the market dips. Outlining downside stretches your strategic imagination.

Reflection prompt: What early warning sign would indicate I’m sliding toward worst case?
Micro-action: Bullet three outcomes with one metric each (e.g. revenue, margin, NPS).

Part 4 – Debrief and Distil

After decision execution (ideally within one week and again at one month), revisit your journal. Compare forecasts to reality, pinpoint deviations and extract one learning. Over time, this builds a personalised playbook of what works - and what doesn’t.

Reflection prompt: What pattern have I seen across recent decisions?
Micro-action: Summarise your single biggest insight in a sentence.

Putting the Habit into Practice

Schedule a Weekly Review – Block 30 minutes each Friday to review new and recent decision entries. Measurable outcome: track the number of debriefs completed each month.

Share Select Insights – In your next leadership forum, present one debrief finding. Pro Tip: Frame it as a question to invite challenge rather than a lecture.

Embed in Governance – Add “Decision Journal Highlights” as a standing agenda item in quarterly strategy reviews.

Common Challenges We’ve Seen

• Surface-Level Entries: Leaders jot down one-line notes without context. Remedy: Use prompts (e.g. “What keeps me up at night?”) to deepen entries.
  
  
• Skipping the Debrief: Entries pile up unused. Remedy: Tie debriefs to existing rhythm - link to performance or risk reviews.
  
  
• Blame-Avoidance: Teams sanitise failures. Remedy: Cultivate psychological safety - celebrate “intelligent failures” that reveal hidden assumptions.
  
  
• Over-Complex Templates: If journaling feels like administration, it won’t stick. Remedy: Keep it under 200 words per entry - short and sharp wins.
  
  

Executive Reflection Corner

Prompt 1: Which recent decision would have turned out differently if you’d journalled your assumptions?
Prompt 2: Spend five minutes sketching one pattern you see in your successes and one in your misfires.

Value Realised

• Faster strategic pivots – by spotting flawed premises early.
• Resilient culture – as candid insights build collective learning.
• Sharper collaboration – when debates are grounded in documented reasoning.
• Continuous skill building – leaders hone their foresight through reflection.

Your Next Strategic Move

• Action this week: Open your journal; choose one decision you face and complete Parts 1 and 2 by Friday.
  
  
• Share one insight or question in the comments below, or email us your experience at vishakha.singh@habitsforthinking.in.
  
  

Team SHIFT

‍

‍