A Fortune 100 tech company, seven VPs, one urgent transformation. Each exec smart, seasoned, and swamped. We were facilitating a leadership offsite, and yet again, momentum stalled at the same fork: pursue internal innovation or buy and integrate. The problem wasn’t lack of insight. It was reflex. Each leader defaulted to their functional lens - engineering pushed for control, finance flagged risk, product lobbied for speed.

During a break, the CFO muttered, “We don’t need new ideas - we need new instincts.”

That was it. What she named wasn’t a capability gap. It was a habit gap.

‍

Why This Matters: The Leadership Reflex Problem

Senior leaders don’t suffer from lack of intelligence, experience, or frameworks. They suffer from mental ruts. When under pressure, we all revert to our comfort zones. For leaders, that often means rehearsing old arguments instead of generating fresh ones.

And this isn’t just anecdotal. Research from McKinsey & Company suggests that nearly 70% of leadership team decisions stall or degrade due to internal inertia, not external constraints. The issue? Leaders think fast, but not always wisely.

The ability to build and sustain better thinking habits isn’t just a nice-to-have. It’s a leadership imperative. Because what you practise in low-stakes moments shapes what you default to in high-stakes ones.

‍

Our Framework: The 5R Habit Loop for Leaders

We call it the 5R Habit Loop - a disciplined approach to rewiring leadership instincts through intentional micro-practices.

1 - Reveal the Reflex

Before you can rewire anything, you need to name it. Which mental habits keep playing out? What assumptions are calcifying? Most leaders never interrogate their defaults.

Example: One CEO we worked with prided himself on decisiveness. But his habit of ‘fast close’ decisions left his executive team disengaged and reactive.

Try this: Over the next 5 meetings, note when you speak within the first 60 seconds. What drove that impulse - insight or urgency?

Reflection prompt: What’s one leadership reflex I lean on that once served me well but may now be limiting?

‍

2 - Reframe the Cue

All habits start with a trigger. For leaders, common cues include: silence in the room, conflict, missed KPIs, or ambiguity. But those cues don’t have to lead to the same behaviours.

Enterprise example: A regional director used to jump in with answers whenever her team hesitated. Her reframed cue? “When it’s quiet, ask a question before offering an answer.”

Micro-action: Write down 3 situations that routinely trigger knee-jerk responses. For each, script a new question to ask instead.

‍

3 - Rehearse the Replacement

This is where most change efforts falter. Insight isn’t enough. Habits are body memory. You need reps.

A pharma exec we coached would instinctively grill her direct reports during quarterly reviews. She wanted to be thorough; they felt under attack. We built in a rehearsal loop: every Friday, she practised ‘curiosity check-ins’ - 10 minutes with each VP focused only on listening and asking “What are you learning right now?”

Pro Tip: Pair up with a peer for ‘habit practice rounds’ - roleplay tough moments before they happen. Build the muscle before the real test.

‍

4 - Reflect with Feedback

Reflection alone can become navel-gazing. What sticks is feedback-fed reflection. Invite one or two trusted colleagues to watch for specific behaviours and reflect them back.

Senior leaders often complain they don’t get feedback. But when was the last time you asked for it - on a specific habit you’re trying to shift?

Micro-action: Send this prompt to a colleague: “I’m working on pausing before I respond in meetings. Over the next two weeks, could you note when I do it - and when I don’t?”

‍

5 - Reinforce with Rituals

Habits don’t thrive in the abstract. They need cues, containers, and community. Rituals provide all three.

One CHRO we admire ends every leadership team meeting with this ritual: each person shares one ‘belief check’ - a moment when they noticed themselves letting go of an old assumption or seeing a problem differently. It’s brief. It’s vulnerable. And it builds a shared culture of cognitive renewal.

Start here: Choose one habit you want to anchor. Link it to an existing ritual (e.g., weekly review, stand-up, or check-in). Make it visible and repeatable.

‍

Embedding New Habits in the Day-to-Day

Building leadership habits isn’t about grand reinvention. It’s about strategic embedding. Here’s how we coach teams to anchor new thinking patterns:

Pick One Habit Per Quarter
Don’t stack goals. Choose one cognitive habit to shift, and live it for 90 days.
Example: Replace “solve fast” with “surface all perspectives first.”

Set a Visible Cue
Use objects, visuals, or calendar nudges. One COO used a red Sharpie on his notebook to remind him: “Stop. Ask. Listen.”

Log Tiny Wins
At week’s end, jot one moment where you noticed the habit shifting.
Pro Tip: Use voice notes if typing slows you down.

What Gets in the Way (And What to Do About It)

These are the most frequent derailers we’ve witnessed:

• Going too broad: Trying to “be more strategic” or “less reactive” won’t work. Make it specific and observable.
  
  
• Confusing insight with integration: Just because a new model makes sense doesn’t mean it’s taken root. Habits need rehearsal, not just reading.
  
  
• Neglecting environmental design: If your calendar, peers, and rhythms don’t support the new habit, friction will win.
  
  
• Dropping too soon: Behaviour change isn’t about streaks. It’s about reboots. Expect resets, not perfection.
  
  

‍

The Thought Leader’s Corner

Prompt 1: Which leadership habit of yours would your team most want you to retire?
Prompt 2: What’s one thinking habit you admire in a peer - and how might you adopt a version of it this quarter?

Set a 10-minute timer. Write freely. Then schedule a check-in with yourself (or a coach) to review it in 30 days.

‍

The ROI of Habit-Built Leadership

Leaders who treat habits as strategic infrastructure - not side projects - see real gains:

• Shorter decision cycles with better alignment
  
  
• Greater psychological safety on teams
  
  
• More adaptive responses under pressure
  
  
• Consistently stronger cross-functional collaboration
  
  

The cumulative effect? Leaders who scale better. Teams who trust more. Organisations that think forward, not just fast.

‍

Make It Count This Week

Here’s your one non-negotiable move:
Choose one leadership reflex to unlearn. Share it with a peer. Schedule your first rehearsal.

We’d love to hear which habit you’re shifting - and what’s changing as a result. Drop us a note or a comment. Because building better thinking isn’t a solo sport.

Team SHIFT

‍